Upcoming Productions

The news is out! Join us for mainstage excitement, youth programs, and and more one-night-only cabarets:

mainstage
Rent

February 6-9, 2025 • The Everson Museum

BUY TICKETSmeet the cast
The Wedding Singer

October 2025 • More information coming soon!

youth programs
The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical

Summer Youth Production (Ages 12-High School)
July 2025 • More information coming soon!

Madagascar: A Musical Adventure, Jr.

Summer Youth Camp (Grades 4-7)
August 2025 • More information coming soon!

Youth Programs

Summer Youth Production
(Grades 8-High School)
The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical — July 2025

Summer Youth Camp
(Grades 4-7)
Madagascar: A Musical Adventure, Jr.— August 2025

Special Events

Coming soon: more information on cabarets and more!

Recent Productions
Pippin
october 25-november 3
Thanks for coming!
October 25, 26, November 1, 2 • 7:30pm
October 27, November 3 • 3pm

Heir to the Frankish throne, the young prince Pippin is in search of the secret to true happiness and fulfillment. He seeks it in the glories of the battlefield, the temptations of the flesh and the intrigues of political power (after disposing of his father, King Charlemagne the Great). In the end, though, Pippin finds that happiness lies not in extraordinary endeavors, but rather in the unextraordinary moments that happen every day.

Directed and Choreographed by Kate Lemos Brown. Music Directed by Lynnette Brown. Vocal Directed by Derek Greabell.

read the reviews
August: Osage County
May 3-11

A vanished father. A pill-popping mother. Three sisters harboring shady little secrets. When the large Weston family unexpectedly reunites after Dad disappears, their Oklahoman family homestead explodes in a maelstrom of repressed truths and unsettling secrets. Mix in Violet, the drugged-up, scathingly acidic matriarch, and you’ve got a Pulitzer Prize-winning play that unflinchingly and uproariously exposes the dark side of the Midwestern American family.

Note: Viewer discretion is advised. August: Osage County contains mature themes, including familial dysfunction, addiction, and emotional turmoil. The play features strong language and confrontational dialogue that may not be suitable for all audiences. Viewer discretion is advised, especially for individuals sensitive to these themes or those uncomfortable with depictions of intense family dynamics.

The subject matter of this play is for mature audiences only and does not reflect views and values of the First Presbyterian Church of Baldwinsville.

Directed by Adam Shatraw

READ THE REVIEWS
Forever Plaid
January 26-February 4, 2024

On the way to their first big gig, tragedy strikes Forever Plaid, a "guy group" specializing in barbershop quartet harmonies and pitch-perfect melodies. Forever Plaid begins when the guys are given the chance to perform from the afterlife. This smash hit musical is a nostalgic homage to the music of the '50s and includes hits such as "Three Coins in the Fountain" and "Love is a Many-Splendored Thing."

Cast:
Caleb Butchko • Jinx
Kilian Crowley • Sparky
Bryan Straub • Frankie
Rob Searle • Smudge
Marshall Pokrentowski • Swing

Directed by Bob Brown. Music Directed by Colin Keating. Choreographed by Shannon Tompkins.

READ THE REVIEWS